So let’s take this actual example: There’s [email protected] and [email protected]. They talk about the same thing, but are treated by the current federation implementation as separate instances.

How would you feel if there was a moderation feature to import another federated instance’s community into your own, so that the posts from the other instance automatically show up in the same feed? That way, you only have to subscribe to one community on one instance, but you get content from multiple instances. I’m not talking about crossposting or mirroring/duplicating posts between communities, only displaying the posts from another instance the community’s home server federates with, with moderator discretion.

  • Flelk@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    4 years ago

    Shit, is this not how Lemmy is intended to work already? I’d assumed this was part of it being “federated.” Clearly I have some things to learn.

    • WuxinGoat@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      4 years ago

      I too had presumed that there was going to be a way to federate communities across instances into one feed, based on the mutual agreement of course.

    • AgreeableLandscape@lemmy.mlOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      edit-2
      4 years ago

      I mean, right now federation is in its infancy so more advanced federation options haven’t really been implemented, and this isn’t something you want done by default, because two communities focusing on different things might have the same name. For example, “trees” might be referring to cannabis (a joke that originated on Reddit), or a biology community about actual trees.

      • Flelk@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        4 years ago

        Makes sense not to do it by default, but I think the option to form a single coherent community across servers is crucial to avoiding platform-killing fragmentation. Otherwise what’s even the point of being “federated?” It’s just a bunch of separate servers.

        • poVoq@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          edit-2
          4 years ago

          You can add [email protected] as a subscription to your account on lemmy.ml and it will be treated more or less as if it was a (!) community on lemmy.ml. This is what federation was always about.

          What the OP is suggesting is more like distributed communities, a bit similar to matrix.org chat rooms. Federated content is AFAIK already replicated on the connected server, so it seems feasible to implement something like that, but there are probably some details in the ActivityPub specs that make it difficult to do so (for example: I think AP does not allow substituting the sender).

          • dragonX@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            5
            ·
            4 years ago

            the problem here is discoverability! as it stands in all Fediverse projects fewer instances host the majority of the fediverse users. because without being able to discover threads of other instances from the one you signed-up to, those smaller communities will not be active enough and will end up duying.
            We must think of ways of merging the feed form different communities of different instances so the user feels like interacting with one big universe rather than separate communities.

          • Flelk@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            4 years ago

            You can add [email protected] as a subscription to your account on lemmy.ml and it will be treated more or less as if it was a (!) community on lemmy.ml.

            Sure, but again I come back to the question of, what’s the point of being federated then? I may as well just be using a local client to present me with a set of RSS feeds from different websites or something.

            What the OP is suggesting is more like distributed communities, a bit similar to matrix.org chat rooms.

            And that’s how I’d assumed Lemmy was going to work until I saw this post. It seems intuitive to me that subs of the same name would at least have the option to “sync” across servers.

              • Flelk@lemmy.ml
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                6
                ·
                4 years ago

                Why would [email protected] be synced in any way with [email protected]

                Interesting, I hadn’t contemplated the idea of topic-dedicated servers. So looking at multiple servers through lemmy.ml is functionally equivalent to using a local client to pull the data from each server separately. I don’t think that’s a bad idea, it’s just not what I’d assumed.

                As I said in my initial post, clearly I have some things to learn! I’m not a programmer, just a superuser with an interest in finding an alternative to Reddit’s increasingly invasive and restrictive platform.

                That said, I do still like the idea of giving subs the option to “merge” if so desired. It’s an interesting layer of complexity to add on top of what I’m realizing is already a fairly complex system.

                • Maya@lemmy.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  5
                  ·
                  4 years ago

                  Small nit: it’s not like pulling data from each server separately because you can have one user account on one server and vote / comment / post in communities on all the servers using that one same identity.

                  • Flelk@lemmy.ml
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    ·
                    4 years ago

                    So what’s the role of the server in account creation/maintenance? Others could take the name “Flelk” on other servers and parade around pretending to be me, meaning readers have to check the domain name to confirm whether it really is me? If my “home” server deletes my account, does that erase all my votes, comments, and posts on just my “home” server, or on all servers?

                    (I know you folks are busy actually building this thing, so if there are better ways to get answers to these questions other than asking you admins directly, please feel free to point me in that direction.)

              • sibachian@lemmy.ml
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                5
                ·
                4 years ago

                then what’s the point of lemmy? a federated community is in a sense centralizing communication through multiple isolated servers. if each one is isolated from the other, and we have 10 different discussion hubs focusing on [email protected], [email protected] etc, then the community is severely fractured and lemmy as a platform doesn’t work as it doesn’t take advantage of the integration at all. for it to work as a platform, cooking.com should be able to choose if it wish to include [email protected].

                • Dessalines@lemmy.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  3
                  ·
                  4 years ago

                  The point is you can follow federated communities from any server. Not that those communities are “shared” by several instances. What you’re talking about isn’t federated, it’s merging. Does mastodon let you merge users across instances?