@yogthos Building walled gardens apps where you control everything is easier than building a walled garden OS where you control everything.
One is an App and the other is an OS, but both can be turned into a “walled garden trap” for consumers.
“But they did it” isn’t an excuse to do it more. We have enough of this going around already with Apple and X and WeChat, governments and tech bros trying to maintain control over the masses. Nah.
I don’t see the OS providing a unified UI that allows people to write apps as services as a problem. I’m likewise confused about what you’re actually try to say here. You’re conflating your ideological stance with technical functionality as far as I can tell. It’s perfectly possible for an open platform to do the same things WeChat does, and that would result in a much better user experience than the current approach. I don’t know why it’s so hard for you to grasp this.
@yogthos They literally JUST banned and unbanned Tiktok at the whim of an annoying orange, and Twitter as we knew it is dead because of a rich billionaire.
You’re glossing over real problems in the name of good ux.
@yogthos Doing inside an app is easier and significantly more of a power-grab.
I’m not sure why its easier, and don’t see how it’s more of a power grab than what Google and Apple already do with their platforms.
@yogthos Building walled gardens apps where you control everything is easier than building a walled garden OS where you control everything.
One is an App and the other is an OS, but both can be turned into a “walled garden trap” for consumers.
“But they did it” isn’t an excuse to do it more. We have enough of this going around already with Apple and X and WeChat, governments and tech bros trying to maintain control over the masses. Nah.
Both Android and iOS are very much a walled gardens last I checked.
@yogthos Right so are you saying we should make the problem bigger?? I’m confused what you’re trying to say here
I don’t see the OS providing a unified UI that allows people to write apps as services as a problem. I’m likewise confused about what you’re actually try to say here. You’re conflating your ideological stance with technical functionality as far as I can tell. It’s perfectly possible for an open platform to do the same things WeChat does, and that would result in a much better user experience than the current approach. I don’t know why it’s so hard for you to grasp this.
@yogthos They literally JUST banned and unbanned Tiktok at the whim of an annoying orange, and Twitter as we knew it is dead because of a rich billionaire.
You’re glossing over real problems in the name of good ux.
What does this have to do with anything being discussed here.
@yogthos Everything, this entire thread and several others that people have started with you.
It’s worth saying twice:
The client-server pattern perpetuates power imbalances, and “Super apps” make that problem much much worse.