- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
You must log in or register to comment.
Whoa Black Betty, Amber-Lang.
Why?
I think it’s to make it easier to write bash scripts, for those who are new or when the script is doing a more critical task
Modern Syntax
You will find many of the language features familiar, allowing you to get up and running much faster than if you were learning Bash from scratch.
Runtime Safety
It’s one of the key components missing from regular shell scripts. It can help you catch many bugs at compile time.
Type Safety
Amber ensures that you handle everything that could fail. Each Bash command and function that could fail must be handled in some way.
Ok, I guess that makes sense. Bash is a pretty old school language for those raised in the functional programming era
So if you’re already pretty good at bash would you bother to switch and learn this?
Never heard of this language, but you’d be surprised how hard it is to write a correct and portable shell script.
Personally, I’d break out python once the script gets larger than a few lines, or rust if I want something more proper.
So basically the TypeScript of bash.
I love the concept. I hate many of the language design choices.
Like what for example?
For me, after looking over the docs, it’s close enough to JavaScript that it might as well adopt more of the syntax (for example, conditionals and loops don’t use parenthesis). It also has some similarities to python, but again not enough to be python.
Feels like an in-between language that has enough similarities to seem easy, but some gotchas that will regularly catch you out.
And then some extra features like the if chaining, which doesn’t have the keywordiforswitchin it. So you have to know that that structure implies an if or switch conditional.Especially for something like bash scripting, which devs probably don’t spend as much time doing compared to python or js. So, it would probably take them longer (and break their brain more) than just scripting it in python/js directly or dealing with bash directly.
It’s an improvement over bash, and it’s nice that it transpiles to bash.
I might have to play around with it and see how it actually feels to useI found the if-blocks more concerning than the lack of parentheses. Although I would’ve preferred parentheses for better parity with Kotlin for the if-else blocks (instead of
then).
Don’t like it one bit
If bash is hard to program, get away with it, not build atop of it.
I like the concept…
okay but the author has to write it, why not write something useful open source?
For fun or to play around with transpilers?
There’s babashka, why?
We need a way to watch for replies to comments without commenting ourselves… (not an answer to your question, sorry)
I mean, my comment isn’t really meaningful either so, touche, Internet stranger.
No, I meant I was following your comment, as I am interested in the answer to your question.
Was posted a few hours before and has many comments: https://beehaw.org/post/13943043
I mean if you want a shell language that behaves more like a regular programming language, PowerShell core is a thing.
When JavaScript developer starts writing a Linux script.
