Would a Federation warship like the Defiant out gun a Star Wars Star Destroyer? Who has a bigger armada? Who has the tactical advantage? Don’t forget that The Federation includes the Klingons, who love warfare and have fast, agile, heavily armed ships, with cloaking devices, and the Vulcans with superior logic and tactical planning.

  • Guy Fleegman@lemmy.dbzer0.comEnglish
    151·
    8 months ago

    It depends on whether you are approaching the question from a narrative perspective or an empirical perspective.

    Narrative: The Federation wins because the Federation are The Good Guys™ and the Empire are The Bad Guys™. The Federation starts out on the back foot and it looks pretty grim in the middle, but ultimately they eke out a win. If this is a TNG two-parter it plays out the way “The Best of Both Worlds” did: engineering prowess combined with timely application of the human factor wins the day. If this is a DS9 arc or Discovery season, then Section 31 does what needs to be done.

    Empirical: The Empire crushes the Federation like a bug. The Imperial industrial base is enormous and their power generation capabilities vastly surpass anything the 24th century Federation can muster:

    • The Death Star could violently destroy an entire planet, reducing it to asteroids. In “The Die Is Cast,” a combined Romulan-Cardassian fleet requires multiple volleys to simply glass the surface of a planet.
    • The Millennium Falcon—a ship a little larger than a runabout—could cross the known galaxy (Tatooine on the rim, Alderaan in the core) in a day. Voyager estimated a similar journey would take 70 years at maximum cruising speed.
    • In the 2360’s the Federation built six Galaxy-class ships and maybe a few dozen more throughout the course of the Dominion war. These are among the largest, most powerful, most advanced ships the Federation can build, yet they are dwarfed by an Imperial II-class Star Destroyer and the Empire built hundreds of these in the mere two decades it existed.

     

    It you could somehow snap these two spacefaring nations into existence and pit them against each other, it would be like late-WWII United States facing off against Napoleonic France. It’s a blowout.

    • teft@lemmy.world
      11·
      8 months ago

      Empirical: The Empire crushes the Federation like a bug.

      I see what you did there.

    • CileTheSane
      53·
      8 months ago

      The Empire doesn’t have shield technology. I don’t know if their weapons could penetrate shields, but they definitely have no defence against a teleporter. Yes, their fleet could get to any target faster than the UFP, but as long as the target has a teleporter system they can just teleport the commander into space.

        • CileTheSane
          7·
          8 months ago

          Fair point. I didn’t remember seeing shields in space battles when watching SW, but forgot about that.

          • ProstheticBrain@sh.itjust.works
            1·
            8 months ago

            The point about transporter tech still stands but there are lots of shield references in SW though they have different types.

            Deflectors - used to protect against physical objects like walls, rocks, torpedoes.

            Ray shields - used to protect against energy weapons and organics. Can’t find any good GIFs atm but from memory, the exhaust port in the first death star was ray shielded, which is why they had to use proton torpedoes. See also, all the silly opening and closing gates in the final battle in Phantom Menace.

    • samus12345@lemmy.worldEnglish
      2·
      8 months ago

      Good thing Luke had the power of narrative on his side! Once the Emperor was gone (for now), the entire Empire went with him (for now).