I’m looking at win % in a table like this. Everton’s is 45.8%

Only 3 teams have a win % above 50. They are

• Arsenal 50.5%
• Liverpool 56.8%
• Manchester City 50.3% (who have by far the most games played of the 3)

Of the rest of the notable clubs,

• United’s is 49.7%
• Chelsea’s is 48.8%
• Newcastle’s is 47.4%
• West Ham’s is 44.0%
• Leeds is 41.5%
• Spurs is 46.5%
• Aston Villa’s is 42.7%

For context

• Leicester’s is 41.2% having played the 3rd most games all time in the 2nd division
• Sheffield United is 43.1%
• Birmingham City is 41.3%
• West Brom is 43.0%
• Ipswich is 40.8%
• Sunderland’s is 42.8%