• 0 Posts
  • 16 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 4th, 2023

help-circle





  • I have no doubt that more games and more minutes aren’t helping. But this article is extremely lacking on actual significant data.

    Is a 15% one time event, significant in 4 seasons? Was it a trend going up or something? Why only use 4 years and not a longer trend?

    I can’t access the data, since the article doesn’t mention it and the linked site only has current data.

    The only thing they mention is this:

    This season there has been an increase of about 96% for hamstring injuries compared to the last campaign, with 53 incidents - 26 more than during 2022-23.

    Overall, it accounts to a 55% increase compared to the previous four-season average. The previous high was 40 hamstring injuries during the 2020-21 season.

    Which is more evidence that 1 data point isn’t really useful. We know that 2020-21 had 40, then 2022-2023 had 26, then 2023-2024 has 53… How can you claim anything with data like that?









  • They still wouldn’t be as bad as the first group. In fact, before he started playing for the NT, Poland was 22nd in 2007, 24th in 2006, 22nd in 2005, and so on… The hovered around 20-30 the decade before him. Their average ranking since 1992 is 35.

    So not really. They would be a bit worse on average, and likely wouldn’t have reached their best rankings which were with him. But their “typical team” historically has been significantly better than the most of the teams I mentioned above.


  • Yeah but if you look closer Poland is ranked 30 in the FIFA Rankings (I know, but as an approximation it works) and these are the goals and the current ranking of the other teams (I know, they weren’t the same before, but just as a guide):

    6 vs San Marino (207)

    5 vs Romania (47)

    4 vs Armenia (91)

    4 vs Andorra (153)

    3 vs Montenegro (68)

    3 vs Denmark (18)

    2 vs Kazakhstan (100)

    1 vs Albania (62)

    1 vs Sweden (23)

    1 vs Hungary (32)

    He scored 18 against teams significantly worse than Poland (San Marino, Armenia, Andorra, Kazakhstan) and then other 9 vs teams that are worse even if it’s closer (Romania, Montenegro, Albania).

    You play whoever you get to play. Not shitting on him. But Poland being unimpressive is on the context of the Top UEFA teams, but the most goals came vs teams that are much weaker.

    And again, not shitting on Lewa, all top players score more on worse teams, so did Cristiano, Leo, Suarez, etc.