• 0 Posts
  • 112 Comments
Joined 17 days ago
cake
Cake day: September 1st, 2024

help-circle
  • Why does it really matter that issues can be “discussed” if the issue being discussed is as atrocious as what Israel is doing to Palestine.

    Israel and the US know that what they’re doing is wrong. Them and their crony countries aren’t going to change course because of this.

    It doesn’t exactly prevent WW2 if they tell Hitler to stop and he doesn’t listen…unless of course they choose to let him continue his goals unimpeded rather than go to war, citing their documented disagreement as sufficient counter action…









  • Then you’re letting sentiment drive you rather than reason.

    So you wouldn’t want the genocide to end if it came at the cost of someone killing themselves? Why?

    Is the entire Palestinian population who are suffering a genocide worth less than a western life to you?

    But I refuse to allow that someone’s opinion should be given more weight than mine just because they mutilate or kill themselves.

    His opinion holds more weight than yours because he is right and you are attacking a martyr rather than focusing on the cause he was martyrd for.

    Their mental disorder doesn’t confer moral superiority, it detracts from it.

    Your insistence that they must be mentally ill/disorderd doesn’t negate moral superiority, it only further reveals your apologist mindset.



  • You’re saying the Democrats, who are welcoming immigrants into sanctuary cities and fighting to protect the rights of legal immigration, are somehow also responsible for fear-mongering about immigrants?

    I’m saying the Democrats who have accepted and now push the 2016 right wing framing on immigration and the border as a national security threat are fear mongering about immigrants yes. Her official platform literally has

    Vice President Harris and Governor Walz believe in tough, smart solutions to secure the border, keep communities safe, and reform our broken immigration system. As Attorney General of California, Vice President Harris went after international drug gangs, human traffickers and cartels that smuggled guns, drugs, and human beings across the U.S.-Mexico border. As Vice President, she supported the bipartisan border [far-right] security bill, the strongest reform in decades. The legislation would have deployed more detection technology to intercept fentanyl and other drugs and added 1,500 border security agents to protect our border. After Donald Trump killed the border deal for his political gain, she and President Biden took action on their own — and now border crossings are at the lowest level in 4 years [why is this good if people crossing the border aren’t bad], their administration is seizing record amounts of fentanyl, and secured funding for the most significant increase in border agents in ten years. As President, she will bring back the bipartisan [far-right]border security bill and sign it into law. At the same time, she knows that our immigration system is broken and needs comprehensive reform that includes strong border security and an earned pathway to citizenship.

    That’s an interesting take. What do you call it when Republicans…

    Whataboutism. “The Republican party are evil so it’s alright that the Democratic party is evil too!”.

    Edit: Also, I call them the thought leaders for the future of the Democratic party as they shift further and further right on these issues in the name of "compromise " and “reaching across the aisle”




  • That’s unfortunate

    It’s unfortunate that you would rather attack a man for the way he opposes a genocide than move on and oppose a genocide yourself.

    You can’t support him because it would support his truth that we are all culpable, and you can’t face that reality.

    And yes, it is America’s fault he has genocide on his conscience and felt compelled to go to such measures, he is a victim of America’s genocide. Was Hitler just suicidal in that bunker? Or do you recognize that external actions can influence such things in that case, and just choose to remain ignorant in this one?

    Would you like me to be pro-suicide.

    I would like you to be a sympathetic understanding human being opposed to genocide, who even if they don’t agree with this man’s actions themselves, recognizes the context they exist in and focuses towards the true goal of opposing a genocide, rather than attacking a righteous martyr.

    But that’s a tall ask for Americans in the core of the genocidal imperialist project, unfortunately.






  • And your time would be better spent electing better leaders instead of setting yourself on fire.

    So I take it this totally isn’t just your excuse/rationalization for attacking someone actually willing to take action against genocide and you will be following through on your idea?

    So which candidate will you elect who opposes the genocide?..

    Anyone who tacitly supports the genocide and doesn’t do everything in their power to bring an end to and oppose the genocide is culpable.

    There is no form of protest against ongoing genocide which can be deemed “too extreme” because any form of protest will pale in comparison to the genocide.


  • The people who need help are the ones who can sit by and criticize people for their opposition to a genocide.

    It’s not some silly game. Our lives are not more meaningful than Palestinians, this is awful, but it pales in comparison to what we are putting Palestine through.

    For some people, not taking any action they can to try and stop the genocide, no matter how hopeless, is worse than death. When the pain becomes unbearable…

    This man is a martyr and a hero, and he didn’t kill himself, the US and Israel killed him in the name of their genocide.