Not really, however both the death of Boromir and the siege of helms deep were relatively verbatim (as your misgivings are concerned, there are differences).
The Ghost army only kills the corsairs in the books, so your problem with the green wall of death killing the entire Mordor army is on point.
It’s a matter of taste and interpretation, however.
In truth, I don’t hate the movies, and I’ll surely watch them again soon. Its just that these scenes really broke the immersion i had, i feel it could have been done much better
Not really, however both the death of Boromir and the siege of helms deep were relatively verbatim (as your misgivings are concerned, there are differences).
The Ghost army only kills the corsairs in the books, so your problem with the green wall of death killing the entire Mordor army is on point.
It’s a matter of taste and interpretation, however.
That is for the added info.
In truth, I don’t hate the movies, and I’ll surely watch them again soon. Its just that these scenes really broke the immersion i had, i feel it could have been done much better
I somewhat agree, mainly on the ghost army part. I love Boromir’s sacrifice though.