This is the comment that got me back out of lurking mode. Hi. Apologies if any of what I write goes against the Solarpunk ethos, it’s not something I know the details of, just the broad ideas.

So, the Middle East has a weird relationship with solar power. I will split this into two parts for two very different regions:

In the Gulf, solar installations have been gaining momentum as essentially vanity projects to show the world “Hey, look, we’re not all dependent on fossil fuels! Look at this n million dollar investment we made into solar power! We are actively participating to become more sustainable!”. I applaud any initiative to harness some of the sun’s free power, I think it’s not a net negative when they do this. But it is worth mentioning that these places really have no drive to push away from burning fuel for their main source of power. It literally comes out of the ground, of course it made sense to use it before all the money came in, but these solar projects are really just puff pieces. I am glad they are building these arrays but they certainly aren’t part of some solar revolution. If we want to look at sustainability more broadly, it’s not like the urban planning, transport infrastructure, or labor conditions are geared towards sustainability. This is a part of the world where sustainability is seen as a tech thing, hell, a tech feature. “Oh you like the environment? Your single-family home must have a dedicated Tesla charger!”. But the Gulf is its own thing. I do believe that since that part of the world is going to be dealing with the effects of climate change head-on, and they will be figuring out stuff like how to deal with microclimate management and so on. I’m not familiar with that kind of science, I want to be optimistic about something.

They do have to keep cleaning the panels though, it’s really dusty out there.

I cannot really speak for Palestine, but I do know about the relationship my country has with solar. I’m from Lebanon, a place with a climate very different from the Gulf (for now). You may remember from a few years ago we were in the news for a bunch of reasons: Record protests, economic meltdown, the whole port incident, all fun things. In 2021 I remember seeing articles pop out from western news outlets with “uplifting” stories about how many households in Lebanon are setting up rooftop solar. Sadly, those stories are not uplifting. Solar (PV) is not this great liberator that the average household is setting up to become more environmentally friendly or independent from the (very terrible) power grid/power mafia (let’s not get into the mafia thing or this comment would be 10x longer). Solar is something only the top 10 odd percent of households can afford, so it’s kind of given us one more layer of inequality here. Don’t get me wrong: my own household installed solar, at what for us is a significant financial investment, and I can tell you for a fact that for people here it is absolutely life-changing. I haven’t had 24/hour electricity in my lifetime, it’s really only something I saw in hospitals. My life is so much better, I can do things overnight thanks to battery storage, I don’t have to worry about how some appliances react to having their power taken away for anywhere between half a second to a few minutes. Things just work and it is amazing.

But the inequality angle I think is being lost on a lot of us, and I find myself forgetting that not everyone has electricity after midnight. We have never been particularly wealthy - I remember seeing photos of my friends on vacation abroad as a kid and asking my parents why that wasn’t something we would do - but now those same friends roll their eyes when I suggest we play one more round of a game at 11:50 PM. There’s a weird survivor’s guilt with being able to pay your way out of a problem. I’m a true believer in household solar, this isn’t just a “throw money at the problem” thing - my country runs on diesel and I hate it so much. The main power stations are ancient and inefficient, and have been converted decades ago (inefficiently) to burn diesel. The mafia generators that used to fill the gaps in power run on diesel. Heating runs on diesel. I hate the smell of diesel smoke interrupting the fresh mountain air, I hate the sound of generators in the street. I hate the generator mafia shaking us down monthly, and I hate them even more after they started pulling more dirty tricks after we installed solar. But this is so worth it, and it’s been worth every dollar (and dollars aren’t as easy to come by here). It has been a life changer for me and my family. If only we can generate water from the sun :p

I hate to make this a “woe is us, Lebanon has it really hard” comment, especially with the manmade hell that has been unleashed in Gaza, but yeah, the Middle East has different areas with different relationships with solar.

I also think Jordan has a PV manufacturing plant, I guess that’s nice.