My group is playing Abomination Vaults, and on the second level there is a room with an undead Minotaur Skeleton Warrior. The book specifically states that it never leaves the room it’s in.
My group quickly figures this out and would simply have everybody ready an attack, one PC would open the door, triggering everybody else’s reaction, and would then close it again.
After doing this about 10 times they finally took down the skeleton despite it having resistance to most of their attacks, with none of them taking any damage.
This is a somewhat inexperienced group that doesn’t usually do strategy things, so I was happy to see them plan and execute.
Anyway what’s the weirdest way your group beat a supposedly challenging enemy?
Even with the minotaur skeleton, I’d argue that it has enough object permanence to know that the things it’s trying to kill haven’t just ceased to exist because it can’t see them. I’d have let the players do it for like one round (an entire round of free damage is still a big reward for clever tactics) and after that have the skeleton start attacking the door itself.
They were dealing like 5 damage a round due to resistances lol
Even if the minotaur smashed the door, it would be attacking through cover to try and hit them in the hallway, and wouldn’t be able to enter the hallway
I think it depends on how experienced the players are. Players without a lot of experience get a lot out of feeling like they outsmarted the game, and it can lead them toward seeing the wider possibilities outside of just hitting the enemy really, really hard.
But definitely don’t let them do the same trick in multiple encounters.