Earl Campbell was scary good, just had a relatively short career.

It’s not all about stats. Bradshaw barely threw more TD’s than INT’s over his career and he was a solid HoF lock (different era, yes). Rings do count, but so do “flashy” stats. Ben’s 4 games over 500 yds passing is one of those for example.

Brady is an obvious lock. Rodgers is a lock. Ben is a lock. Eli gets in because of beating Brady in the Super Bowl twice. Brees gets in on performance/stats/records. Rivers has a shot but a slim one. Ryan is out.