GnastyGnuts [he/him]

  • 0 Posts
  • 18 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2020

help-circle



  • So, all the neoliberal western countries that largely believe their democracies are also democracies?

    I honestly don’t care if western neoliberal countries see themselves as democracies or not, or if they are democracies or not, since that’s not really my grievance with them anyway. However, in China the idea of democracy that is promoted by the Xi himself is one of majority rule, the same way nearly everybody uses the term. That’s the standard that Chinese people are going to be inclined to measure their government against, especially since their government has actively invited them to think of democracy in those terms.

    Quoting Xi: “Whether a country is a democracy or not depends on whether its people are really the masters of the country. Democracy is not an ornament to be used for decoration; it is to be used to solve the problems the people want to solve.” (from a central conference speech he made in 2021, you can probably find the whole thing if you look)

    That doesn’t sound far off from “western” notions of democracy, does it? That’s the idea of democracy that they’re being “indoctrinated” with over there, and what the vast majority of Chinese citizens believe their government lives up to.


  • Ofc indoctrinated citizens think they’re a democracy, they also probably have different understanding of democracy

    How do you justify dismissing it as indoctrination? And if the majority think of it as a democracy, under what definition or understanding of democracy is the perspective of the majority not of prime importance?

    America isn’t a democracy either but people are brainwashed into believing it is. Most of the Americans that choose “not a democracy” in that poll are Republicans that’ll say “democracy is mob-rule, we’re a Republic!”

    The first part of this I agree with (other than the notion of brainwashing), but I don’t understand where you’re getting the second part. According to that poll I linked about perceptions of democracy, 73% of US citizens value democracy, which doesn’t fit with 51% thinking it’s not a democracy, but liking it that way because they think democracy is mob rule.

    Does this look democratic to you?

    I don’t consider the contentiousness of elections to be of primary importance when evaluating if a government is democratic, but given the measurable advancements that have occurred in China under Xi’s leadership, I can buy that he would have such immense support, particularly if there isn’t an equally appealing alternative with such a proven track record.


  • Most of the time they don’t forgive debt and when they do it’s corrupt [emphasis mine]; they’re trying to win them over to become satellite states one day.

    What do you mean when you say their debt forgiveness is “corrupt”? And why do you believe that they want to win them over as “satellite states” and not as regular-old geopolitical allies?

    Ok, they’re nicer than the west, that doesn’t mean it’s not still imperialism

    What about it makes it imperialism to you? Do you see any difference at all between lending money for development projects and imperialism? How does forgiving loans facilitate economic domination of these places?

    From that news.com australian article I posted: “But the concept of a Chinese “debt trap” has also been criticised, with a study in 2020 finding China had restructured or refinanced about $21 billion of debt in Africa between 2000 and 2019. The study also noted there was no evidence of “asset seizures”and that Chinese lenders had not used courts to enforce payments, or applied penalty interest rates to distressed borrowers.” For a go at economic imperialism, they don’t seem keen on putting the choke-hold on.