I created this community on Lemmy.World because I am giving up reddit and would still like a forum to discuss my favorite games.
This community is for discussion of any zelda game, not limited to the current switch games.
What is your favorite Zelda game?
You must log in or # to comment.
Totk was the best,
That moment you fall from the starting area island is incredible and only surpassed by two other moments in the same game that I’m not gonna spoil
Twilight princess. Art direction was top tier. Great linear story. Tons of memorable characters. 10/10 would play again
i’m gonna chime in with wind waker. i haven’t played a good bit of the zelda games, especially the modern entries, but wind waker is still easily one of my favorite games of all time. absolutely amazing aesthetic, fun characters and story, with one of my favorite worlds to explore and navigate in any game. mileage may vary depending on how cool you think sailing is ⛵️. still has one of my favorite final boss encounters and endings in any game i’ve played.
I loved sailing on the GameCube version, and never actually got to experience the remake with the Swift Sail. Personally it felt like a grand adventure, with a beautiful musical score. I never found sailing to be tedious. It was cemented for me when you have to get back to Outset Island in order to beat the pirates there first. The raging storm while sailing and the tone was so well done. Love this game so much.
ToTK of course. For all intents and purposes it’s BoTW with added mechanics. And of course I love the additions to the map, the new sky and depths areas are dope.
If we’re talking more traditional Zelda I’d say Twilight Princess. That game has so much personality and atmosphere and it’s got my favorite iterations of the series’ characters… and Midna is bae of course.
I would say Majora’s Mask. I loved how weird it was and the time reset.
I have two favorites
Majora’s Mask - I’ve always considered this to be the best Zelda game. The various side quests in the game worked perfectly with the 3 day time loop. They managed to make the world feel like there were real consequences to the actions Link took. The side quests made it feel almost like Link was a detective, sorting out clues and figuring out who was going to be where so that on the next loop, you would be able to progress further down a questline.
Wind Waker - Despite the fact that I consider Majora’s Mask to be the better game, I find that Wind Waker was more fun to play. The graphics style, the soundtrack, and the sailing mechanic all made for enjoyable and relaxing gameplay. I usually get impatient when having to travel around but hopping on the boat and sailing from island to island was itself enjoyable and not just a means of getting from Point A to Point B. Also, the graphics style helped the game hold up even as time passed. When I would go back to play Ocarina of Tiime or Majora’s Mask, it would feel like the sharp polygons were stabbing my eyes, but I can boot up my gamecube and play Wind Waker with no problems.
Ah! I miss Majora’s Mask. That truly was a masterpiece. I have a theory that the second Zelda on each console is a more experimental game where the designers can focus more on story and risky mechanics because they can reuse a large portion of the game engine, and thus the costs are a fraction. So Majora’s Mask was always my go-to example of that theory. Now with TotK, I can kind of confirm that. They doubled-down on the sandbox design and even reused the overworld.
It’s a real shame that WW never got it’s engine reused for a second gamecube Zelda.
Great point. Totally makes sense as we have the testimony - generally the second game on the console reutilizing the same assets is objectively better.
Ocarina of Time (N64). Not only do I have fond memories with playing the game while snacking on bugles but the nostalgia is great too. The game was fairly open world and some of the cringe aspects are really amusing to me as well. By far not a perfect game, but perfect for me.
Honestly, I feel like Ocarina of Time revolutionized the gaming industry at the time. So many games have followed the formula since then and we have gotten some really awesome games.
I’m 46. From the moment I played the original back in the day, I’ve been a huge fan of the entire series. My all time favorite (so far) is Wind Waker. I played that for the first time a few years ago and spent so much time goofing around. Before I played that, I was a huge fan of Ocarina, having bought it when it first came out on the N64. Every Zelda game I’ve played has been a huge step up from the previous.
Another favorite of mine is Link to the Past. That one kept me involved for a few years. I kept going back through it because I really enjoyed the story and gameplay. Link Between Worlds was a fantastic sequel.
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed all the remasters on the switch too. 100%'d Link’s Awakening and finally got the play through Skyward Sword. I’m sincerely hoping for a reissue/remaster of Twilight Princess because I didn’t get to play that much on the Wii. My kids hogged that system so I rarely got to play anything beyond Wii Sports.
I recently started Breath of the Wild and after initially being stuck and giving up trying to get into the first divine beast, I’m now ready to infiltrate Hyrule Castle a couple years later. I only picked BotW back up because of all the TotK hype. I can’t wait to play it!
I love Windwaker. I know it got a lot of flack for the design style, but it is honestly one of my favorite games of all time.
If you are enjoying BoTW, you are going to love Tears of the Kingdom. It builds on and expands BoTW in every way.
I absolutely loved the design of Windwaker when I first saw screenshots. Cell shading was brand new and it looked incredible to me. I never played it when it was new (I didn’t really play any GameCube games), or when it was remastered for WiiU. I finally played it and was hooked.
My son has been playing through TotK and I’ve caught glimpses of it here and there. The sheer size of the map is mind boggling in comparison to BotW. So excited to get to it… after BotW, of course!
when i was a kid i had the option of playing on n64 with ocarina or a gamecube with wind waker. unfortunately ocarina didn’t stand a chance to a kid easily impressed with bright colors. funny how it caught flak for that design, but nintendo was effortlessly reaching its target audience.
Both of my kids were HUGE GameCube fans. They were right at the target audience age range. I kinda got out of gaming around that time so I missed the whole GameCube era. Tried to get into the Wii and WiiU eras but my kids stayed on those systems 24/7 so I didn’t stand a chance. They let me play briefly every now and then, but not long enough to get invested in anything. I can’t just play Zelda games for a couple minutes. Especially these days. Even after all this time, Nintendo reliably produces games I consistently play and go back to.
I agree dude, that’s my favorite thing about Nintendo - the first party games are so well done. The Wind Waker is my all-time favorite, with sometimes Majora’s Mask creeping up and threatening to take the title.
It’s tough to pick a favorite because each one you’ve played is so special. I haven’t ran into any Zelda game I’ve played that I’d consider average or a dud. They’re all fantastic in their own right.
Meanwhile I hope one day, if you have that desire, you’ll play some of the other titles you’ve missed out on. Skyward Sword for example is great, despite its flaws.
It is definitely very difficult to pick a favorite Zelda game. They are all really well done.
I have to admit, I was never a big fan of Majora’s Mask. I played a TON of Ocarina back in the day, but MM just didn’t resonate as much with me. Life started getting hectic with the kids getting older, which is when I started having a lot less time for gaming for a while. I need to go back to it and give it a playthrough regardless of my initial impression.
I did play a good bit of Skyward Sword HD on the Switch. My son let me use his account so I could play some new games, but I don’t have access to it now. I just need to buy it so I can finish it. It was a little different, but I was enjoying it. I could emulate, but I’m already so far into it lol.
Link to the Past for me, but it’s 100% nostalgia goggles.
The game that got me into video games. I recently played it this year (after this game turned 30) and thoroughly enjoyed it. It’s amazing that I still had the game almost committed to 100% memory. I only had to look up a few things that I had forgotten and didn’t want to spend the time getting lost in the game to figure it out for myself (I’m old now and can’t be bothered. :D )
Meanwhile, I played A Link Between Worlds when it came out on 3DS, and that game hit so many nostalgic notes. The gameplay mechanic and 3D effect was so well done.
Love these two games tremendously, but they’re not my favorite Zelda. That crown goes to the wind waker.
