A female student alleged the school’s uniform policy was discriminatory against females
The school said the allegations were “offensive and baseless”
The tribunal found there wasn’t enough evidence to conclude the student was being treated unfairly because she was female
[The Tribunal] said while female students may feel the cold when in skirts during winter, the evidence submitted did not address whether stockings or tights would resolve that issue, or whether female students had an advantage during summer compared to male students wearing trousers.
wtaf
Even more wtf:
The concern of modesty was also dismissed by Mr Gordon given that the skirt was required to be long enough to touch the ground when kneeling, and the uniform policy permitted girls to wear shorts underneath their skirts.
If they’re “permitted to year shorts” why not just skip the skirt and let them wear shorts?
My point exactly, I mean it just seems absurd. The question is: what is gained by wearing a skirt?
I think I know the answer…
Good on her for trying I reckon. Fucking uniforms are shit, pointlessly gendering them is even shitter.
OTOH it helps children with lesser means have a way to be on the level with other children as far as that goes… Growing up in a place when/where brand names just started popping up on clothing, shoes etc. and you couldn’t afford being a walking advertisement was tough (however, it has shaped my wardrobe as the majority of my clothing has no obnoxious branding)
Gendered uniforms are still shit, but there is a place for uniforms if done properly.
https://studyfinds.org/school-uniforms-student-behavior/
I tend to think that for every kid that does better with uniforms, there is a kid that does worse.
Students with lesser dress sense as well. When I started uni I discovered a whole new anxiety I never knew I had, about trying to fit in which bothered me for the first couple of years and stopped me from going to classes, at least now I’ve given up caring. But the school uniform was good for people with social anxiety like me, if I had this bothering me at school it would be a whole different thing.
At the same time I think the school uniform policy in question here is stupid. I’m not female so I can’t relate to this but only imagine. It seems like QLD state schools are allowing the female students to wear pants. I will admit that I haven’t read the article but sounds like a pretentious private school
ahaha no it doesn’t. we all know who bought the cheap hand me down uniforms and you’d be amazed what accessories can be used to separate the elite from the proles
Mate, we all knew who the less well off children were growing up. You don’t need clothes for that.
I dont fucking get it. If you’re going to force uniforms, just let anyone wear any of the uniform “styles”. Let anyone wear the skirts if they want to, who does it hurt. Let anyone wear the trousers, who does it hurt!
“Separate but equal” never is. If you have rules that only apply to some students - cut that shit out.
Get the males wearing skirts and that policy will likely get an update.
The school’s uniform policy stated girls in years seven to 12 needed to wear skirts to occasions including excursions, ceremonies, and class photographs while male students could wear shorts or trousers — their usual uniform.
I don’t think they would be allowed to.
I’m thinking they mean in protest, e.g. https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/jun/22/teenage-boys-wear-skirts-to-school-protest-no-shorts-uniform-policy
Girls can’t wear pants… is this the 1950’s? Absolutely awful
yeah nah. Wtf
