I used to play piano when I was a kid and I want to get back into it now that I’m older. I think I have more patience for it now, but I don’t have room for a large keyboard. I’m thinking of a small midi keyboard like a oxygen pro mini or mpk mini plus. Do they need to be plugged into a computer to work or can I just connect headphones to them directly? I know these are stupid questions, I’m sortof new at all this. If they have to be connected to a computer, are they compatible with linux, are there any good linux apps to use with them? I don’t mind small keys, and I do prefer nice key feel over more midi features. I’m probably not gonna record anything.

Lemme know if this is the wrong place to ask this.

Thanks.

  • Piers@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Having occasionally been able to have a play with pianos and thinking I’d like to learn to play I’ve been trying to find the same thing. So far I’m looking at the Casio CT-S1. It’s a 61 key piano focused keyboard (so while it doesn’t have the weighted keys you’d find on an actual digital piano, it is a little closer to the feel of a piano than a typical keyboard) with great built in sounds and speakers plus midi over USB for use as a midi controller with your computer. They’re designed specifically to be highly portable so they are light and have a relatively low footprint for a 61 key. I dunno about the US market but in the UK they’re generally available around £200 so I expect it’s likely to be about $200 over there. People also seem to rate the Yamaha E373 but from what I understand it has a more keyboardy key style (ie, rounded rather than flat ends, no texture and very little resistance) and it is a bit bulkier and more complex to use. The flip side is that you get way more sounds (though I gather that the high quality sound selection is similar between the two) and more direct control to edit and adjust those sounds. There’s also the Roland GO:Piano, which is overall quite similar to the Casio CT-S1 but I hear the key-feel (whilst possibly more piano-like than the E373) isn’t as good as the CT-S1.

    Ultimately there just aren’t any affordable non-88 key digital pianos. The big difference being the key action. The three keyboards above all offer great piano sound and dynamic playing (ie, the harder you press the louder it plays). It seems (having not had the chance to try any of them myself) like the CT-S1’s key feel is the least un-like a piano’s of the three.

    The next step up would be something like the Roland FP-10 but that’s nearly twice the price of these keyboards (and personally I’ll have to save a looong time to be able to afford a £200 one so that’s out until I’m seriously committed) and, while they are portable digital pianos, between the full 88 keys and all the extra bulk and mass of a proper weighted keybed they’re still gigantic and heavy compared to some of these “piano”-style 61 key keyboards (not to mention that I hear you have to always keep digital pianos horizontal or you eventually damage the weighted key mechanism, whereas afaik a portable keyboard is more flexible in how you store it.)

    • dotfiles@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 year ago

      Thanks for the detailed post, you’ve got great suggestions in there. I bought an Arturia Keystep 37 a week ago and it’s fits my needs ( and my desk) perfectly. It’s got arpegiator and sequencer features and 4 customizable knobs that I can map to DAW software options. I really like how the keys feel, even though they are mini keys.

      • Piers@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        1 year ago

        I think I misunderstood what you meant by not having room for a large keyboard as specifically not a full 88 key like a piano.

        • dotfiles@lemmy.worldOP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          It’s cool. I wish Roland or Korg made a 61 key digital piano with weighted keys. I think I could maybe make room for that, but I’m not buying it anytime soon.

          • Piers@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            1 year ago

            I think the 73 key Yamaha p-121 is the shortest keybed proper digital piano around. Though they are in the process of releasing their next generation of portable digital pianos so maybe they’ll eventually make a new shorter keybed in there somewhere.