I agree, the cross-posting gets annoying. Why do people insist that everyone who is interested in a certain topic needs to participate in their post, so it has to go on every community?
People did not do that on reddit. They just made one post and waited for interaction.
It’s more that every sub had much different levels of activity so one repost would get attention while another dwindled.
The issue with Lemmy is activity is not centralized so each individual repost sees roughly as much activity as the other, so as far as sorting goes, they’re all considered to be as equally active, i.e. “Hot”. It’s all kind of flat line across communities.
We just need more activity, more people, more voting, making making more posts.
I didn’t see it very often at all. Unless you’re talking about memes and repost bots or something.
But when someone made some random post about their life or some story or question or something, they would just post it to one spot. Like 98% of the time.
This is the natural effect of the core structure of this platform.
And it’s only going to get worse as the user base increases and instances start to defederate one another due to differences in acceptable content and conduct.
I know saying anything the least bit critical of Lemmy means lots of downvotes, but the whole system seems far too prone to fragmentation and the repetition necessary to make up for it.
The whole appeal of Reddit was that it was a one stop shop for key discussion on the topics you were interested in. No matter how many similar communities popped up there was usually one subreddit that was the spot for a topic, and other similar ones were only viable if they focused on a specific niche. Here, it’s completely possible that there might be 20 communities on exactly the same subject that have 90% of their content overlapping…and you have to be subscribed to all of them if you want the extra 10% of unique stuff they bring to the table.
The dream was that each instance would bring something different so the collective would be a mosaic of unique(ish) communities
The reality is that each community is an overlapping subset of the communities defined by the social sites like Reddit, going all the way back to Usenet groups
I mean, the core is no different. You can make communities here, you can make communities there. There was nothing stopping you from making duplicates there, and many people did.
I think this is really just a sign of Lemmy’s early status, and people’s perception of it is more of an illusion that’ll change with time. It’s really just that we don’t have any actual large communities yet. Whatsoever.
I agree, the cross-posting gets annoying. Why do people insist that everyone who is interested in a certain topic needs to participate in their post, so it has to go on every community?
People did not do that on reddit. They just made one post and waited for interaction.
there were tons of cross posts on reddit, it’s just that they usually weren’t visible on the front page as such
It’s more that every sub had much different levels of activity so one repost would get attention while another dwindled.
The issue with Lemmy is activity is not centralized so each individual repost sees roughly as much activity as the other, so as far as sorting goes, they’re all considered to be as equally active, i.e. “Hot”. It’s all kind of flat line across communities.
We just need more activity, more people, more voting, making making more posts.
The cross posts on reddit were terrible.
Same fucking post on awww, upliftingnews, mildlyinteresting, bustypetite, etc
That was different, you’d more rarely see one individual cross-posting to tons of subs. Instead it would be many individuals cross-posting.
That I do not have a problem with. 5 users starting 5 threads is different from 1 user starting 5 threads. Every cross-post is not equal.
People did this constantly on Reddit, I don’t know what you’re talking about.
I didn’t see it very often at all. Unless you’re talking about memes and repost bots or something.
But when someone made some random post about their life or some story or question or something, they would just post it to one spot. Like 98% of the time.
This is the natural effect of the core structure of this platform.
And it’s only going to get worse as the user base increases and instances start to defederate one another due to differences in acceptable content and conduct.
I know saying anything the least bit critical of Lemmy means lots of downvotes, but the whole system seems far too prone to fragmentation and the repetition necessary to make up for it.
The whole appeal of Reddit was that it was a one stop shop for key discussion on the topics you were interested in. No matter how many similar communities popped up there was usually one subreddit that was the spot for a topic, and other similar ones were only viable if they focused on a specific niche. Here, it’s completely possible that there might be 20 communities on exactly the same subject that have 90% of their content overlapping…and you have to be subscribed to all of them if you want the extra 10% of unique stuff they bring to the table.
The dream was that each instance would bring something different so the collective would be a mosaic of unique(ish) communities
The reality is that each community is an overlapping subset of the communities defined by the social sites like Reddit, going all the way back to Usenet groups
I mean, the core is no different. You can make communities here, you can make communities there. There was nothing stopping you from making duplicates there, and many people did.
I think this is really just a sign of Lemmy’s early status, and people’s perception of it is more of an illusion that’ll change with time. It’s really just that we don’t have any actual large communities yet. Whatsoever.
deleted by creator