Love songs are difficult to capture, but this image definitely captures the emotion. A beautiful song to play while with someone you love.
The artist, from new jersey, (I hear he had blue eyes) has sold over 150 million records… wow. This was his final single to top the easy listening chart in 1967. Please enjoy.
answer
Frank Sinatra - the world we knew (over and over)
You have given such awesome clues! Love song, 1967 absolutely narrowed it down, but the last panel gives it away. Red stars, blue night.
The time is right, your perfume fills my head
The stars get red, and, oh, the night’s so blue
And then I go and spoil it all
By saying something stupid like “I love you”
Something stupid by Frank and Nancy Sinatra
you are very close… but not correct. i’ll post some more hints below
Answer added to main post
a phrase that may mean “tumbling?”
this is a good hint. the lyric is from the first line of the second verse