• 833 Posts
  • 1.91K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 3rd, 2023

help-circle









  • I understand the question.

    Oh good! 😮‍💨

    OP is asking what the English variations there are throughout the world.

    Then why did she ask about Norwegian? Why did she say “of your language” rather than English? Why did she answer my question by saying she means dialects from the Americas?

    I am curious if Jamaican Patois would count as a different language entirely

    There’s no academic/formal definition of what counts as a different language rather than a variant. Then it gets politically contested: peoples who want to assert their separatedness claim their language is totally different (e.g. Ulster Scots). That’s one reason if you ask “How many languages are there in the world?”, linguists tell ya “Between 4000 and 8000”











  • Hi luv, thanks for the discussion.

    A few things come to mind:

    • Firstly, ‘the West’ doesn’t really exist, not in the very realist sense. It’s a label of convenience.

    • Secondly, people dislike the West for exploiting (in other words expropriating, in other words taking) the wealth from the rest of the world. You mention ‘tankies’, who are materialists. Is it hard to understand why a materialist would expect an individual proletarian to follow the resources to the country that has accumulated them?

    • Putting the above point more simply: UK extracted $64.82 trillion from India during colonial rule — which is the answer to both your questions. That explains both why people dislike the UK and why Indians have an incentive to move to the UK


    If you think the West is evil, corrupt, racist, bad, why don’t you try moving out?

    Have done. Loved it. Reluctant to give too many autobiographical details, but Africa is a wonderful place, people’s attitudes are more humane, less hurried and calculating.


    We would love to hear your thoughts too. What are YOUR reasons for liking-or-disliking the so-called West and for living there or not?