Hundreds of years of innovation in water travel, and we come back to a sail. Granted, a metal one, but still a fucking sail.
Hard to beat the efficiency of just having energy delivered to you for free…
Those damned sails stealing the earth’s winds for free.
Global warming you know why it’s happening? Because the sails are all stopping the global winds! No winds to blow the heat away and it all warms up! BAN SAILS TODAY to MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!
The scale of a sail needed to propel a giant cargo ship is really quite a bit different from what you might imagine on an old frigate, aka a “pirate ship.” Making a sail that large out of traditional materials is not feasible, and would require a ton of people to operate it. One of these monstrosities is staffed by probably less than 20 people, and labor is expensive, so this sort of computer operated sail can be both feasible and cost effective, whereas old school type sails were not
What’s old is new again. Time is a flat circle. But really, technology has a good habit of compounding gains. One new idea applied to a hundred old ones really gets innovation running hot.
saved an average of 3.3 tons of fuel each day. And in optimal weather conditions… reduced fuel consumption by over 12 tons a day. According to Cargill’s math, that’s an average of 14 percent less greenhouse gas emissions from the ship. On its best days, Pyxis Ocean could cut that down by 37 percent.
This is fascinating. I got questions.
What’s the ROI? Is it a no-brainer to install these things for the cost savings? If not, and if they prove out, governments should look at making them mandatory and providing partial subsidies. Or, maybe an easy loan to jump start adoption?
This video answered some more questions. They do indeed fold down for rough weather and clearance and appear to rotate 360°.
I’m assuming they’re computer controlled for max efficiency?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AB7cLkSVmJA
Not seeing any downsides here.
The biggest downside I could see is the sails getting in the way of cranes.
According to that video, they fold out of the way. I’m not sure if they currently fold on the real ones. The article mentions:
the 125-feet of height added by WindWings could potentially complicate docking in many locations. According to Jan Dieleman, president of Cargill’s Ocean Transportation business, they’re already working to address such issues.
Which seems to imply they don’t. Their solution of modifying ports to accommodate the sails might mean the folding aspect wasn’t viable?
Not sure about this one example but working in the industry and following the development of wing sails the ones I’ve seen will fold one way or the other. This example in the article is probably a prototype or even experimental implementation to test the efficency.
Examples of folding sails in development: https://www.theoceanbird.com/oceanbird-wing-560/
You wouldn’t need them in port so make them easy to disconnect or compact into a smaller space.
Looks like this only works for bulk haulage and wouldn’t be compatible with intermodal freight (shipping containers)
Why wouldn’t it? Those sails are 37m tall. I found stacked containes to be at max stacked up to 25m.
At a guess, because the 25m of containers only leave you with 12m of sail sticking out of the top.
You can’t make the sail higher, as you’d just end up rolling the ship.
seems like they could make that a solar panel and a flat battery at the same time as being a sail
Making it a battery would likely add a lot of weight while taking away structural integrity.
Solar yes battery would be a problem from a weight stand point. That much weight that far out could cause acrwy things.
In the other hand hard say of the solar would be that useful for the cost to install since there is no guarantee it would be facing the sun correctly. Creating a deck cover of solar though could be useful.
I think these new fangled bendable solar panels might work. The bog thing to know is that cargo ships already are diesel-electric, so you can just immediately consume any generated electricity (reducing load on the engine and saving fuel).
You want low weight for stability on a ship and batteries are heavy
Imagine reinventing sails and thinking you’re innovating.
They did innovate on them a great deal, honestly.
You’ll be shocked to find that electric cars have been invented 50 years before Benz came around with what today is considered the “invention of the automobile” by slapping an internal combustion engine on it.
You can’t use traditional sails on a ship of that size and mass, they wouldn’t make much difference and would need a large crew to operate.
If you want to apply the concept to modern ships, you need to design stronger sails (e.g. made of metal), you need to make it easy to operate with a small crew and you need to also design them in a way that doesn’t interfere with cranes in ports.
It’s not as easy as just slapping sails and calling it a day.
