• @LittleTarsierEnglish
    7•1 month ago

    I think part of the issue is there’s multiple communities on different instances for the same topic. I’m subscribed to like 4 different movie communities. If we all just stuck to one, maybe there would be better engagement?

    • @[email protected]OPEnglish
      6•1 month ago

      That’s interesting, because I can exactly tell you why there are so many movies communities

      • [email protected] got created but is pretty much unmanaged. People on LW just post there out of habit, or because they support LW
      • there was historically a moviesandtv on an instance called lemmy.film. It was getting some traction, but then the instance disappeared
      • to keep another instance out of LW, people (including me) got involved into [email protected]. It was going well, but at some point I suggested to have discussion threads for current movies, and to engage more with the community. The mod found that “backseat moderating” and banned me. The details can be found in the spoilers in the OP here: https://lemmy.world/post/11446250?scrollToComments=true
      • I thus took over [email protected], to kind of have that space to discuss movies.

      I think we might consider posting to [email protected] to promote the two others on Lemm.ee. I actually did that 2 months ago to talk about the Dune discussion thread we had on [email protected]: https://lemmy.world/post/12820343?scrollToComments=true

      18 upvotes, no comments, and that’s it. I guess a few people went there, but I’m not sure.

      • @LittleTarsierEnglish
        2•1 month ago

        Well, that’s ridiculous! I imagine there are similar stories for other communities as well which ends up with a bunch of fragmentation.

        • @[email protected]OPEnglish
          1•1 month ago

          I agree with you.

          I even escalated the “power tripping” of the mod of [email protected] at the time to the admin instance, but their stance was that they didn’t want to interfere with the moderation of communities, as that would be themselves powertripping.

          I’m going to post to the LW community to advertise [email protected] at least

        • @[email protected]MEnglish
          1•1 month ago

          I imagine there are similar stories for other communities as well which ends up with a bunch of fragmentation.

          We narrowly avoided fragmentation with [email protected] and [email protected]. Some amount of consolidation is definitely a good thing especially since Lemmy’s userbase is still small.

      • @[email protected]English
        2•1 month ago

        Dang, this sucks. I usually post news rather than open discussions so I never noticed. I had my own disagreements with lemm.ee admin back in the day which is why I’m on sopuli.xyz among some other things.

        I do wonder if going with movies community on an instance that has more broad one already is too much of a handicap. Something like beehaws’s c/entertainment could work if parked at some instance that’s federated well enough.

        • @[email protected]English
          3•1 month ago

          Open discussions are always the hardest things to get comments and actual conversations in the comments, except maybe in the AskLemmy community where it works well.

        • @[email protected]OPEnglish
          1•1 month ago

          I do wonder if going with movies community on an instance that has more broad one already is too much of a handicap

          It might be, I just posted on [email protected] (not wanting to get another account banned on [email protected] ), we’ll see how it goes

          I don’t think that’s much of an issue to be honest, and even if it is, having a “large” audience able to see it from their local feed should outweigh the con.