Watching Star Trek Strange New Worlds, I’m enjoying so far after watching season 1, but I personally think Paramount appeals for nostalgia more than a new public, specially with lots and lots of reference who only fans will catch.
And I start to remembering those people who complaing about Star Wars or Fallout, with the idea of franchises which need a 360 grades turn to bring something new, for example, Fallout fans complain about the overuse of Broterhood of Steel, something I think is a silly thing to complaing since is almost the face of Fallout franchise is a whole.
But my question is; do Star Trek fans has the same opinions and thoughts? Of letting go the franchise?
Image as example, also, I’m waiting for respectful discussion and not flamewar.
I love the hell out of SNW, but I agree that as a TOS prequel it’s limited in its ability to move the franchise forward.
Thankfully, Starfleet Academy has turned out to be really, really good. I just hope it survives and secures a strong enough following.
You’re absolutely right and we’ve been asking for this since the end of Voyager and I think one of the biggest reasons why Enterprise had such rough time.
90s Trek was fantastic and did a great job handing off to each other. Even Voyager being stranded was still moving the world forward. Then we reset back to the first Enterprise, absolutely killing all the momentum.
The best thing Discovery ever did (apart from soft launching Strange New Worlds which got lucky) was launch us into the far future and give us a place to build.
I never would have asked for that. Picard seemed like that path forward, but struggled (season 1), told a what if story (season 2), and then just did a fun reunion (season 3). But ultimately set up a Seven show that just never happened.
But we’re in the far future now. Discovery put us there. Starfleet Academy is building and moving us forward again. It’s not perfect, but it’s building and I’m in.
I feel this is a powerful argument against prequels in general, not just for star trek.
Like, I cant help but think you’re right. The latter half of disco did indeed move the setting to a place where Academy can pick up and it seems like it’s working.
I really wish we got a Captain Seven show or mini series. I had been saying “Captain. Annika. Hansen.” to my friends since Picard commissioned her. Then it happened! One of the best moments in Star Trek. Seven of Nine becoming Captain of the Enterprise.
Academy is really good for the whole franchise. There were some things that I disagree with narratively but it’s bones are solid.
I re-watched the pilot with some friends who were interested because of the dumpster fire online and I played a bit of Star Trek sherpa. I had to explain that the pilot IS NOT the show. The show starts when they land in San Francisco. (And the burn. I had to spark notes the burn. Since they’re still back watching voyager in the timeline.)