The reasons for removal
The post it self: Not an X link, and the post had the video’s description to inform on the topic. The YT Channel in question. The video in question.
The reasons for removal
The post it self: Not an X link, and the post had the video’s description to inform on the topic. The YT Channel in question. The video in question.
I’m not familiar with this post, and unfortunately I don’t think I received any reports for it since I’m from another instance. Best would be to hear from one of the other mods
I do see that there is an X/twitter link in the quoted body of the post, which might be the cause of that part of the message. As for the video, [email protected] had a similar discussion recently on what to do about clickbait titles for videos. It’s a hard one to deal with. As Lemmy grows, I can see it becoming a bigger problem and requiring stricter rules.
So to me it looks like the content is on topic, but it’s a case of quality control
The video is pretty good (the whole channel is something I think the com would like). Still do you feel it would be better for me to change the title to one that is descriptive or keep the title as OP made (likely trying to game the algo)
I feel that I shouldn’t make the final call for moderation in this community since I’m here more as support/spam removal, so I’d go with whatever the other mods decide.
In most other communities, when I’m posting something potentially clickbait-y, I prefer to edit the title and then make it clear that I edited it, either with square brackets or by mentioning the edit in the post body. I might also add why I’m sharing something if it’s not clear (ex. that the analysis is good, or the channel is something the community would like). That seems to reduce the chance of complaints/reports/mod actions.
The main exception being the communities that are strict about requiring the original title (ex. News communities mostly)