The beginning of vigilante justice opens the door for a lot of extra judicial punishment/violence that can very quickly devolve into chaos.
If the elite are focused on self preservation while the public attack them; police forces will be unavailable to protect the general public from itself.
By that I mean; criminals that are barely held back by the threat of punishment from the law will see the lack of enforcement as an opportunity. This puts the lives of average citizens in danger.
So; while vigilante justice is an option, it should be a last resort.
There are still paths through the legal system to explore. Congress still has significant power and some of the GOP are beginning to push back. It’s not going to be easy; but it’s still a possibility.
Plus; idk about you, but I’d rather not deal with a bunch a radicalized MAGAts seeking to avenge their fallen martyr. (particularly after showcasing vigilantism for them…)
My dude the police aren’t there to “protect the general public from itself”. The police are there to protect capital from the general public.
Vigilante justice is an individual taking justice into their own hands. But an organized resistance group is not vigilante justice. It is revolutionary action.
Luigi was a vigilante. But when half the country agrees with his actions he is no longer a vigilante when that half takes up arms to resist fascism.
We do not need more individual acts. We need organized acts. The US could learn from the successes and mistakes of groups like the IRA right now. That is “what is to be done”.
the police aren’t there to “protect the general public from itself”. The police are there to protect capital from the general public.
Primary and secondary goals. If they have to put all their focus on protecting capital, they become unavailable to protect the public. Which is something they DO perform; even if poorly or disproportionately.
But an organized resistance group is not vigilante justice.
Then you’re not arguing for vigilante justice, you’re arguing for organized resistance…
This discussion is about how vigilante justice isn’t the answer. (at least, yet).
The beginning of vigilante justice opens the door for a lot of extra judicial punishment/violence that can very quickly devolve into chaos.
If the elite are focused on self preservation while the public attack them; police forces will be unavailable to protect the general public from itself.
By that I mean; criminals that are barely held back by the threat of punishment from the law will see the lack of enforcement as an opportunity. This puts the lives of average citizens in danger.
So; while vigilante justice is an option, it should be a last resort.
There are still paths through the legal system to explore. Congress still has significant power and some of the GOP are beginning to push back. It’s not going to be easy; but it’s still a possibility.
Plus; idk about you, but I’d rather not deal with a bunch a radicalized MAGAts seeking to avenge their fallen martyr. (particularly after showcasing vigilantism for them…)
My dude the police aren’t there to “protect the general public from itself”. The police are there to protect capital from the general public.
Vigilante justice is an individual taking justice into their own hands. But an organized resistance group is not vigilante justice. It is revolutionary action.
Luigi was a vigilante. But when half the country agrees with his actions he is no longer a vigilante when that half takes up arms to resist fascism.
We do not need more individual acts. We need organized acts. The US could learn from the successes and mistakes of groups like the IRA right now. That is “what is to be done”.
Primary and secondary goals. If they have to put all their focus on protecting capital, they become unavailable to protect the public. Which is something they DO perform; even if poorly or disproportionately.
Then you’re not arguing for vigilante justice, you’re arguing for organized resistance…
This discussion is about how vigilante justice isn’t the answer. (at least, yet).
deleted by creator
Well, to avoid vigilante justice, I think we need everyone to fucking stand up and say “enough”, instead of just going about their lives.
If we don’t, the need for change will boil over into uncontrollable violence.
And that’s not so much a prediction as it is a promise.
Having an authoritarian dictator opens the door to so, so much worse.
Isn’t there going to chaos either way?